The Legal Classification of Men and Women

The Legal Classification of Men and Women

Length: 869 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Usually sex classifications were challenged by women who felt they deprived of equal legal treatment, but they were also challenged by men who felt women were given unfair legal protection. Originally, most of the gender specific legislation in the United States was passed because stereotypes regarding women pervaded the mentalities of many of our nation's lawmakers. Slowly the government realized that women had been sealed into the domestic sphere and attempted to reverse this discrimination by giving women special compensations. In some instances the treatment women received was leftover from old notions of role typing, while in others, laws directly tried to remedy harmful effects of the past. In both cases, men claimed their equal protection rights were violated by laws which separated women from men.

In Stanley v. Illinois 1972, Peter Stanley challenged an Illinois statute which "automatically conferred custody on a married father and on a mother, married or unmarried, and automatically denied it to an unmarried father" after the death of a parent (Goldstein 196). Stanley claimed that his equal protection right, protected by the Fourteenth Amendment, was violated because other parents who were similarly situated, that is, women and married men, were given a benefit which he was denied. A constitutional law must demonstrate a clear goal of the state, and represent the "least restrictive means to achieve those ends" (Mezey 16). In this case, however, the Supreme Court observed "that the State registers no gain towards its goals when it separates children from the custody of fit parents" (Goldstein 199). Clearly this law is a remnant of the past when women were thought to be the only caretakers of children. The underlying motive for this law was "the theory that an unwed father is not a "parent" whose existing relationship with his children must be considered" (Goldstein 198). While it is common for the state to defend their stereotypical legal relics on the grounds of "administrative convenience," the Court now identifies these laws as problematic (Reed v. Reed 1971, Frontiero v. Richardson 1973). "Procedure by assumption is always cheaper and easier than individual determination(,) but when the procedure... explicitly disdains present realities in deference to past formalities... it cannot stand" (Goldstein 200). Thus, the Illinois law which automatically awarded women the custody of their children, but not similarly situated men, was declared unconstitutional, because it was grounded in outdated stereotypes.

Leon Goldfarb, in Calfifano v.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Legal Classification of Men and Women." 20 Jan 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Abolition of Discrimination Against Women in Kuwait

- ... And what does the performance of a group of people are in a position to perform other persons will be admitted in the future, if this provision in advance came on a discriminatory basis has nothing to do with the quality of work but also by the kind of humanitarian. Analysis of case Clearly the illegality of this Declaration is not justification for the distinction between equally qualified persons per legal centers, with fulfillment of all legal requirements required in the job. In this Declaration the Administration use its deviation to the difference in treatment between the prevalence of legal positions and creating differentiation through the Palace to receive requests from the le...   [tags: constitution, rights, kuwait women]

Research Papers
910 words (2.6 pages)

Classification of Crime Essay

- Crime is the form of an act. Every human being has the intention to commit the crime. Crime is the purpose of an act in the destruction of the criminal law (Schmalleger, 2012, p. 2). In general, type of crime can be classified into three major categories; crime against person, crime against property and crime against morality (refer to Figure 1 in Appendix 1). The first type of crime is a crime against a person. A crime against a person is a crime that involves with human beings. There are two types of crime against the person which are murder and rape....   [tags: person, property, morality]

Research Papers
907 words (2.6 pages)

Legal Drugs? The Problems of Alcohol Essay examples

- Heroin, Cocaine, and Marijuana are all recognizable variations of drugs. “A drug is a chemical substance that affects the central nervous system, causing changes in behavior and often addition” (“American” 431). The affects a drug can have on the central nervous system as well as other parts of the body can be very devastating, but bodily damage is just one result of drug use. When a person abuses a drug it can cause them to act in a way that hurts themselves or others often resulting in problems at work, marital issues, child abuse, or even murder....   [tags: Drugs, Cocaine, Marijuana]

Research Papers
1948 words (5.6 pages)

Haney Lopez : Legal Construction Of Race Essay

- ... The slave term is not in the Constitution and it was portrayed as a state of shame that men could be described as property. Rather than using the term slaves, “other persons” was used as a delicacy for their group. Significance: The Declaration of Independence is significant to our nation because it led individuals to gain independence; also, it justified rights that the original government no longer guaranteed certain rights. If it were not for the words written in this document all races now would not be treated equally and women would not have the right to vote....   [tags: United States Constitution]

Research Papers
1492 words (4.3 pages)

The Women's Rights Essay

- Have you ever wondered why women have the rights that they have today and not have to be the way women were supposed to be before. The beginning of all changes started in 1848 and lasted not just till 1920 but even until today. Many leaders such as Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Betty Friedan, Gloria Steimem and Sojourner Truth at the time were supported by both men and women to encourage women to conquer sexism and claim their rights. The whole purpose of the movement is to gain equality for all women....   [tags: Social Issues, Dependency]

Research Papers
1172 words (3.3 pages)

Women 's Rights During The Workplace Essay

- ... Married women in the workplace received less than unmarried women and in some instances women were dismissed afeter married. In 1961 when equal pay for work of equal value was awarded female work was specifically excluded. By 1969 the Australia Council of Trade Unions had turned to the courts to remove the difference between male and female pay rates, the courts ruled that women’s pay should increase from 75 to 85 per cent of the male wage. It was not until 1972 that the Arbitration Commission ruled equal pay for women who were performing the same work as men....   [tags: Discrimination, Employment, Gender, Sexism]

Research Papers
1166 words (3.3 pages)

Should Marijuana Be Legal? Essay

- ... Even though cannabis was used heavily in a majority of medicines in America at the time. The way they accomplished this was by passing cannabis off as it 's unwell known name at the time, marihuana which was what the mexican immigrants called it at the time. The American population not knowing what marihuana was at the time gladly passed the Marijuana Tax Act of 1937 under the propaganda that its use amongst colored men caused debauchery, violence, and the rape of white women. This Act would eventually lead to the overall illegalization of cannabis....   [tags: Cannabis, Tetrahydrocannabinol, Pharmacology]

Research Papers
1421 words (4.1 pages)

Essay about Rise or Decline of Colonial Women

- Rise or Decline of Colonial Women Depending on nationality, ethnic, location, and religious classification women’s lives improved and declined in the Colonial Period. The natives, the Europeans found on arrival to the New World, held their women in the highest regard. This changed with the introduction of European ideals. African women taken from their homes and brought to the New World in the chains of slavery also led to a decline of living conditions. Some European nationalities, like the Dutch, had advanced living conditions until the arrival and subsequent conquer by the English....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
988 words (2.8 pages)

Wage Discrimination against Women Essay

-    The Women’s Equal Rights Movement has made dramatic progress in the last one hundred years. As a result, a woman can now vote, choose almost any career, and defend her human right to happiness. But, in spite of the progress made in the area of equal rights, wage problems in the workplace still exist which deny women equal pay for equal work.   SUCCESSES Women are closing the gender gap in workplace and higher education. They are starting to climb the corporate ladder and are moving into managerial positions....   [tags: Expository Exemplification Essays]

Research Papers
1254 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Equality between Men and Women

- For thousands or even millions of years, almost ever since mankind began, women were considered weaker than men. Women were the ones tending their homes and looking after their offspring. Men were the heroes who risked their lives in search of food to keep their families alive. Thus, over the thousands of years of human civilization the belief that men are superior in strength and intelligence is deeply embedded in everyone’s minds. Feminism grew popular only these 50 years. Let us be realistic, can such a ‘young’ ideal replace a deep-seated belief of thousands of years overnight....   [tags: Women weaker than men?]

Free Essays
371 words (1.1 pages)

Related Searches

Goldfarb 1977, protested "those parts of the Social Security Act which made him ineligible for old-age survivors benefits from his deceased wife's social security payments" (Goldstein 179). The issue in this case was whether it was constitutional to assume that females were economically dependant upon their husbands, and thus refuse social security benefits to men who were assumed to be nondependant. "Congress might have reasonably concluded that it would be both cheaper and easier simply conclusively to presume that wives of male members are financially dependant on their husbands" (Goldstein 181). However, the Judgement of the Court announced that "this statutory scheme discriminated against female wage earners because it gave them less protection for their families than male wage earners" (Goldstein 180) Again, the part of the Social Security Act in question, was ruled unconstitutional because it was the "accidental byproduct of a traditional way of thinking about females" (Goldstein 186). Although the Act was harmful towards men, it was based upon the outdated stereotype which said women were not, or could not be the dominant wage earner in their family.

In Califano v. Webster 1977, Webster challenged another part of the Social Security Act "which permitted women to calculate their "average" monthly earnings by a more generous averaging technique than that granted to men" (Goldstein 192,3). The issue in this case was different than that in both previous cases, in that the challenged statute here was not the result of stereotypical thinking about women, but rather it "operated directly to compensate women for past discrimination" (Goldstein 193). The Court found that there was indeed reason for the State to make gender distinctions of this sort. "Reduction of the disparity in economic condition between men and women caused by the long history of discrimination against women has been recognized as such an important government objective" (Goldstein 193). Therefore, in cases like this, gender classifications are not the result of outdated stereotypes, but the conscious effort of society to improve the conditions of certain under- privileged groups.

The three cases presented here show different ways and reasons the law has classified men and women. When a statute is based upon stereotypes it usually does not have a legitimate governmental goal and the Court declares it unconstitutional. However, the Court characterizes sex as a semisuspect classification which requires heightened, not strict, scrutiny (Mezey Table 1.1 p. 20). This enables the Court to decide whether there can also be a legitimate reason to make a gender classifications. Califano v. Webster is proof that sex classifications can serve a just purpose. These three cases have indeed advanced the cause of gender equality, because they dispelled "overbroad generalizations" where they were present, but held their ground where gender distinctions were necessary to further the cause of equality.
Return to